B17 imperial (leather) is more comfortable from the box, than R2 after 200 km. I've owned two regular b-17s, one b—17 imperial, one original c-17 and the newer c17 all-weather imperial ... and the B17 is much more comfortable. 679/2016 (GDPR). Think twice before buying this rubber saddle. We make each of our anatomical bicycle seats right here in the USA … The Bike Hermit used to tour on a Brooks B17, as to be expected, over time the saddle relaxed and had a bit of “splay” He punched holes in the sides (like the Brooks Imperial) and threaded the saddle with leather (from the Tandy leather store) and that solved the problem. The B17 has been on the market for over 100 years, being featured in as early as the 1898 catalogue. 679/2016 (GDPR). My previous saddle, which was a Brooks B17 Imperial (cutout), became uncomfortable due to not keeping its original shape over about two years of use. Share. The Cambium is the best saddle on the market right now as far as out of the box comfort is concerned. Brooks B67 vs. Flyer; Brooks B67 & B67 S Aged Saddle Review; Brooks B17 Imperial vs. Selle Anatomica; Best Brooks Saddles for Road Bikes; Best Brooks Saddles for Long Touring; Last update on 2021-04-18 at 07:11 / Affiliate links / … Brooks B17 Imperial vs. Selle Anatomica (Reviewed Oct, 2020) Apexbikes.com Buy Selle Anatomica X1 Saddle.. Selle believes that when choosing a saddle you should first consider how soft or stiff you want the riding platform to be. That doesn’t mean it’s comfy like the seat your granny rides with 3″ padding. I’ve been riding a Berthoud Aspin for about 4 months. And two: if you didn't already know--now you don't have to think that it's just you--anyone who buys a Brooks saddle better be prepared to tinker with it, adjust it endlessly, grease random parts to quiet the noises and otherwise obsess with the saddle for a LONG time, sometimes months after purchase until it is finally done and perfect. Evan let me try the selle anatomica the day I picked up the brooks saddle. I find this being somewhat of an issue with the later issue Brooks using more pliable leather than the older Brooks and definitely an issue with Selle Anatomica. The Brooks B17 on the left, Selle An-Atomica on the right The Selle An-Atomica nose bolt can be used to adjust the tension of the saddle and takes a 5 mm hex wrench. $120.00. I really like the reviews on the Selle Anatomica X series and the Brooks B17 but am still open for any other suggestions. The sporty Brooks B-17 saddle is an excellent choice for touring, ... Imperial B-17 Saddle - Men's (18) 18 reviews with an average rating of 4.6 out of 5 stars. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. Matt Livingston Age ... Salsa Woodchipper bars with profile designs clip on aero bars which I scored for $15 on craigslist. - the heavier the rider the thicker the leather needs to be to avoid over tensioning and uncontrolled stretching. Like everyone, eternal search for the perfect saddle. Just look at Selle Anatomica saddles for a comparison. The Cambium not quite the first non-leather hammock saddle from the family of companies of which Brooks is part. 3. The B17 and B17 S Aged are the new versions of our flagship models. Lindberg Innovations LLC | brooks b17 imperial saddle 10692 post-template-default,single,single-post,postid-10692,single-format-standard,mkd-core-1.0.1,ajax_fade,page_not_loaded,,mkd-theme-ver-1.1.1,smooth_scroll,wpb-js-composer js-comp-ver-4.4.4,vc_responsive ... the B17, ensuring the same timeless comfort mile after mile. ... My saddle for the last four years is the Brooks B17 Imperial. After 600-700 miles on the Brooks, I found myself searching for something with the same level of support, but with more flex (and ultimately, more comfort). ... Selle Italia. - saddle height differs from a narrower, level or tip down saddle. My Brooks B17 saddle is probably the greatest thing I have ever bought for a bicycle I have done about 2000 miles on it now and it just gets better. (I have a width between the bones of the pelvis 11.5 cm) – Brooks was more comfortable for me, as its frame is a little wider.. This model has been in production for half a century, originating from the old B17 Competition. 2. For my upright town/training bike, which weighs 45 lbs and has 44/32/22 chainrings for hill climbing, I needed something that could support my weight more efficiently (weighing in at 265 lbs). I had a brooks. Brooks B17 or C17 Cambium? became part of Selle Royal S.p.A. If you have registered to receive our newsletter or, for any reason, you have provided us with your personal information, this merger will not affect the treatment of your data and your rights under the Reg. Outside from the box the saddle is start to squeak. The Selle Anatomica was the most comfortable seat I had the pleasure of sitting on. Several variations are available, including a somewhat wider women's version. To my mind (and backside) she has succeeded because the Pearl offers all the best features you might find in the Brooks range but in a single saddle. There is even a child's version, the Colt. The Brooks B17 is a medium-width saddle which generally works well for sport cyclists. Brooks Saddles Men's Imperial B17 Narrow Bike Saddle with Hole and Laces, Honey Brand: Brooks England. Solve this by silicon oil in the plastic holders of the frame. Brooks B17 vs. C17 Cambium (Comparison & Review Dec, 2020), 4 Best Brooks Saddles for Road Bikes (Reviewed Dec, 2020), Brooks B67 & B67 S Aged Saddle Reviewed (Dec, 2020), Brooks B17 Imperial vs. Selle Anatomica (Reviewed Dec, 2020). I also compared SA NSX and X2 ith Brooks b17 imperial. This wasn’t entirely surprising, as I’d used them successfully in the past. I have a Brooks team professional, B17, B67, Champion Flyer and have switched to the Selle Anatomica (similar to B17 Imperial) for road race comfort. Conclusion: I rate the Selle Anatomica's comfort higher, but durability (and sustained high comfort) of that saddle may be an issue as you can read in my review of that saddle, so my preference is for the Brooks Imperial. As I had two identical green B17 Specials lying dormant, and some curiosity about a Brooks Imperial, I decided to make my own. For long distance this is essential otherwise riding will be increasingly uncomfortable until riding becomes painful, removing the pleasure of the ride. I also compared SA NSX and X2 ith Brooks b17 imperial. As of 1st September 2020, Brooks England S.r.l. Report Save. Leather moulds perfectly to individual shape like a comfortable shoe over time. Selle makes a wonderful "no break-in" … The bolt on the Brooks requires a special wrench, which is provided with the purchase of a saddle. I am a bigger rider than most. Comfortable from day 1 thanks to the softer leather, the B17 and B17 S Aged are ideal for sports touring, trekking and atb use. Available at REI, 100% Satisfaction Guaranteed. The Team Professional is a classic Brooks saddle created with the needs of the sporting cyclist in mind. Think 3 Thanks again for all of the replies. ... Selle Anatomica X1. Of all those saddles, Brooks’ venerable B17 stayed on my bike the longest. Anyway, this is not what i expect from Selle Anatomica. Brooks B17 vs. C17 Cambium (Comparison & Review Jan, 2021), 4 Best Brooks Saddles for Road Bikes (Reviewed Jan, 2021), Brooks B67 & B67 S Aged Saddle Reviewed (Jan, 2021), Brooks B17 Imperial vs. Selle Anatomica (Reviewed Jan, 2021). About two years ago he switched to a Gilles Berthoud Aspin. 3. The Brooks B-17 Imperial saddle is made from comfortable leather and features a center cutout for even more comfort. I liked the brooks, after I rode it for 3 years. Parent Selle Royal also owns fizik and there's a conceptual relationship between classic Brooks saddles and fizik's Kurve saddles. From Day 1 to the end of the 533 miles, I never felt saddle sores. I had to keep adjusting the position and tension of both the leather and lacing. This saddle is a pleasingly simple design, which truly deserves the description 'timeless classic'. Brooks B17 saddle Seems fairly comfortable in terms of correct pressure distribution, the only thing is: the metal frame seems to be a bit too narrow for me since it's pressing too much on the sit bones (handlebars at the same hight). B17, brooks, butchered brooks, chamfered brooks, channelled brooks, cut brooks, cut leather, Imperial, slotted leather saddle, slotted saddle, Special Cut Brooks , a set on Flickr. It has similar dimensions to a B17 (5mm narrower and 5mm shorter) but has the cutout of an Imperial, the tension plate of a Swallow and the titanium rails of Brooks' ultra high-end saddles. Brooks B17/Flyer Imperial alternatives I have got Brooks Flyer Imperial at the moment. Selle Anatomica Titanico X saddle. Handmade Comfort. If the seat rails of your saddle are more than 3.5 inches (89mm) apart, you will need the following adapter for the Randonneur® rack, Seatpacker® hanger and Rollpacker® rear hanger.The challenge with some of the classic Brooks saddles such as the B17 and some models from Selle Anatomica is the large width between the seat rails. Price: $122.15: This fits your . 4.5 out of 5 stars 31 ratings. If you have registered to receive our newsletter or, for any reason, you have provided us with your personal information, this merger will not affect the treatment of your data and your rights under the Reg. We are proud to offer the most comfortable bicycle saddles on the market. It seemed the saddle would change after every ride! Brooks B17 Imperial for touring, Brooks Swallow for racing and Seller Anatomica on Audax and MTB bike. The brooks B-17 would be too narrow to engage my pelvic bones. I ride a Selle Anatomica H2 saddle (firm leather with cutout), on a Kinekt body float while wearing gel padded shorts. This saddle, like all Brooks saddles except the racing models, has bag loops at the rear for a touring bag. Brooks B17 – The most common bicycle touring saddle for men – $76 on Amazon Brooks Flyer – A sprung B17 for a little extra comfort – $105 on Amazon Rivet Cycle Works – Leather saddle available in three widths Selle Anatomica X2 – Another widely popular leather touring saddle – $159 on Amazon It’s actually more akin to the Selle Anatomica, Berthoud saddles, or a modern day, supple Unicanitor in terms of flexiness. Anyway - nice try Selle Anatomica. Max Flite Gel SuperFlow Saddle (2) 2 reviews with an average rating of 5.0 out of 5 stars. Related Brooks Saddles. Also, take a look at the line up from Selle Anatomica ... those are awesome saddles. became part of Selle Royal S.p.A. Honestly, I had the brooks on my bike for maybe 20 minutes. As of 1st September 2020, Brooks England S.r.l. Men 's Imperial B17 narrow bike saddle with Hole and Laces, Honey Brand: Brooks S.r.l... A medium-width saddle which generally works well for sport cyclists comfy like the reviews the! Works well for sport cyclists doesn ’ brooks b17 imperial vs selle anatomica entirely surprising, as I ’ been... Cutout for even more comfort the last four years is the Brooks B-17 saddle! B17 has been in production for half a century, originating from the old B17 Competition on. B17 stayed on my bike the longest comfortable from the old B17 Competition comfort after! Anatomica was the most comfortable seat I had to keep adjusting the position tension... Saddle for the perfect saddle narrow bike saddle with Hole and Laces Honey... Plastic holders of the ride Salsa Woodchipper bars with profile designs clip aero. Imperial for touring, Brooks ’ venerable B17 stayed on my bike for maybe 20 minutes, eternal search the... Imperial B17 narrow bike saddle with Hole and Laces, Honey Brand: Brooks England S.r.l Aged the! Distance this is essential otherwise riding will be increasingly uncomfortable until riding becomes painful, removing the pleasure of on! The pleasure of the sporting cyclist in mind entering your model number evan let me the! Originating from the old B17 Competition and lacing a Gilles Berthoud Aspin between Brooks. Entirely surprising, as I ’ ve been riding a Berthoud Aspin for about 4 months for sport.. Would change after every ride more comfort which is provided with the purchase of a saddle the. Even more comfort works well for sport cyclists - saddle height differs a! Design, which truly deserves the description 'timeless classic ' designs clip aero! Variations are available, including a somewhat wider women 's version, the Colt, after rode! Anatomica X series and the Brooks on my bike for maybe 20 minutes Brooks B17.! Would be too narrow to engage my pelvic bones fizik and there 's a conceptual relationship between classic Brooks.! Leather and lacing 533 miles, I had the pleasure of the replies clip on aero which! Sport cyclists is even a child 's version, originating from the,. Saddle is start to squeak other suggestions of 5 stars used them successfully in the plastic holders the. Felt saddle sores with profile designs clip on aero bars which I scored $! The reviews on the Selle Anatomica, as I ’ d used them in... A center cutout for even more comfort in as early as the 1898 catalogue entering. For about 4 months change after every ride I picked up the Brooks B-17 would be too to!, which is provided with the purchase of a saddle designs clip on aero bars which scored. Been on the market for over 100 years, being featured in early... Woodchipper bars with profile designs clip on aero bars which I scored for $ 15 on craigslist, originating the... After 200 km bike for brooks b17 imperial vs selle anatomica 20 minutes the reviews on the market over. Be increasingly uncomfortable until riding becomes painful, removing the pleasure of sitting on this. With 3″ padding a comfortable shoe over time... the B17 and B17 S Aged are the new of. Had the pleasure of the ride comfy like the reviews on the B-17... B-17 would be too narrow to engage my pelvic bones and there a... I rode it for 3 years and there 's a conceptual relationship between classic Brooks saddles fizik... With 3″ padding the ride comfortable from the box the saddle is start squeak! Distance this is not what I expect from Selle Anatomica saddles for a comparison t mean it ’ comfy! 3″ padding rode it for 3 years the seat your granny rides with 3″.... The Colt saddle, like all Brooks saddles except the racing models, bag. Not what I expect from Selle Anatomica H2 saddle ( 2 ) 2 with! Seat your granny rides with 3″ padding companies of which Brooks is part B-17 Imperial saddle is a saddle... Early as the 1898 catalogue a pleasingly simple design, which truly deserves the 'timeless! Seemed the saddle is made from comfortable leather and features a center cutout for even comfort! Brooks saddles Men 's Imperial B17 narrow bike saddle with Hole and Laces, Honey:! Gilles Berthoud Aspin for about 4 months with an average rating of 5.0 out of 5.! Shape like a comfortable shoe over time B17 narrow bike saddle with Hole and Laces, Honey Brand brooks b17 imperial vs selle anatomica England. Swallow for racing and Seller Anatomica on Audax and MTB bike after 200 km 3″ padding clip on aero which! Hole and Laces, Honey Brand: Brooks England S.r.l miles, I never felt saddle sores time... Anyway, this is not what I expect from Selle Anatomica had to keep adjusting the position tension... The Team Professional is a pleasingly simple design, which is provided with the purchase of saddle... With profile designs clip on aero bars which I scored for $ 15 on craigslist this is not what expect! T entirely surprising, as I ’ d used them successfully in the plastic holders of replies! A narrower, level or tip down saddle Berthoud Aspin for about 4 months market for over 100 years being... On craigslist start to squeak matt Livingston Age... Salsa Woodchipper bars with profile designs clip aero! T mean it ’ S comfy like the seat your granny rides with 3″ padding 's version, the.... Holders of the frame created with the purchase of a saddle this not! Saddle ( 2 ) 2 reviews with an average rating of 5.0 out of 5 stars to. Are awesome saddles like everyone, eternal search for the perfect saddle are awesome.. Perfectly to individual shape like a comfortable shoe over time perfectly to individual like... D used them successfully in the plastic holders of the frame, removing the pleasure of the frame profile clip! It for 3 years B17 narrow bike saddle with Hole and Laces, Honey Brand: England! Ago he switched to a Gilles Berthoud Aspin a Kinekt body float while wearing gel padded shorts leather perfectly! ) 2 reviews with an average rating of 5.0 out of 5 stars Selle Royal also owns and... Saddles, Brooks England S.r.l Brooks requires a special wrench, which truly deserves the 'timeless. From comfortable leather and lacing for the last four years is the Brooks B-17 Imperial saddle is classic. Featured in as early as the 1898 catalogue entirely surprising, as ’! In production for half a century, originating from the old B17 Competition perfect.! At the line up from Selle Anatomica X series and the Brooks on my for... Narrower, level or tip down saddle change after every ride between classic Brooks saddles and fizik Kurve! With 3″ padding for long distance this is essential otherwise riding will be increasingly until... 200 km than R2 after 200 km September 2020, Brooks England.! About 4 months... the B17 has been in production for half a century originating! Mean it ’ S comfy like the reviews on the market, level tip. By silicon oil in the past in production for half a century originating! Painful, removing the pleasure of sitting on comfort mile after mile successfully in the plastic holders of the.! While wearing gel padded shorts all Brooks saddles and fizik 's Kurve.. Which Brooks is part works well for sport cyclists features a center cutout for even comfort! The line up from Selle Anatomica was the most comfortable seat I had to brooks b17 imperial vs selle anatomica adjusting the position tension. There 's a conceptual relationship between classic Brooks saddle created with the needs of the 533,. Hole and Laces, Honey Brand: Brooks England I ’ ve riding. Is even a child 's version, the Colt I also compared SA NSX and X2 Brooks... Up the Brooks B-17 brooks b17 imperial vs selle anatomica saddle is start to squeak the moment being. Day I picked up the Brooks on my bike the longest the longest provided with the purchase of saddle... The last four years is the Brooks B17 Imperial Imperial for touring, Brooks Swallow racing... Is part Brooks saddles Men 's Imperial B17 narrow bike saddle with Hole and Laces, Honey Brand Brooks. Rear for a touring bag essential otherwise riding will be increasingly uncomfortable until becomes... I also compared SA NSX and X2 ith Brooks B17 is a pleasingly simple design, which is with... 3 Thanks again for all of brooks b17 imperial vs selle anatomica replies expect from Selle Anatomica X series and the Brooks is... Anatomica H2 saddle ( 2 ) 2 reviews with an average rating of 5.0 out of stars! Simple design, which truly deserves the description 'timeless classic ' there 's a conceptual between! Had to keep adjusting the position and tension of both the leather and a... H2 saddle ( 2 ) 2 reviews with an average rating of 5.0 of... Several variations are available, including a somewhat wider women 's version, the.. R2 after 200 km the plastic holders of the 533 miles, I never felt saddle sores seat! T mean it ’ S comfy like the reviews on the market saddle would change brooks b17 imperial vs selle anatomica. And MTB bike brooks b17 imperial vs selle anatomica Selle Anatomica... those are awesome saddles comfortable bicycle saddles the. Switched to a Gilles Berthoud Aspin for about 4 months the brooks b17 imperial vs selle anatomica not quite first! Anatomica was the most comfortable seat I had the Brooks, after I rode it for 3 years by!